3 Common Myths About High Deductible Health Plans Debunked

High Deductible Health Plans with HSAs, employee benefits, small business team meeting

If you own a business, you already know that renewal season for employee benefits can feel a lot like opening your credit card bill after the holidays. It’s stressful, it’s usually higher than you wanted, and you’re left wondering if there’s a better way to manage the costs without letting your team down.

This is where we need to talk about High Deductible Health Plans (HDHPs).

You might hear that name and immediately cringe, but stick with me here. Think of an HDHP a bit like your car insurance. If you want a super low monthly bill, you usually agree to pay more upfront in the event of a fender bender. An HDHP does the exact same thing for health coverage: it gives your business and your team much lower monthly premiums, but the upfront cost (the deductible) for service is higher before the heavy-duty coverage kicks in.

But here is the secret to making this work without causing a mutiny in the breakroom: you don’t just hand your employees an HDHP and wish them luck. You take a chunk of the money you saved on those lower monthly premiums and put it into a special healthcare piggy bank for your team.

Typically, this piggy bank takes one of two forms:

When you pair the low premiums of High Deductible Health Plans with the safety net of an HSA or HRA, you create a total win-win. It protects your bottom line while still taking great care of your people.

But, as with anything in the insurance world, there is a lot of misunderstanding out there. That’s why we have specialists in our offices who are experienced in specific industry coverages. Our newest agent, Jason Ferree, is the specialist for employee benefits and health plans, and he’s always happy to answer any questions you may have.

For now, let’s clear up a few common myths about how High Deductible Health Plans actually work in practice.

HSA piggy bank, stethoscope, Health Savings Account

Myth #1: Moving away from fully insured, age-rated exchange quotes is too risky if you have employees with health conditions. 

It’s the local small businesses and mom and pop shops that are driving our local economies. But when it comes to employee benefits, business owners all share a common, recurring nightmare: the annual insurance renewal.

You’re already trying to balance your commercial lines, keep the lights on, and take care of your team. Then, you look at the standard insurance exchange and see those skyrocketing premiums. The prevailing myth is that if your workforce isn’t perfectly healthy, leaving standard exchange plans to explore alternative funding — like level-funded High Deductible Health Plans paired with Health Savings Accounts — is just too much of a gamble.

The reality? Staying in the standard, fully insured market is actually the biggest financial risk to small businesses.

In 2026, annual premiums for employer-sponsored health insurance hit a staggering $28,303 (5% higher than 2025), and those costs are only projected to climb further. When you buy a standard plan, you don’t get those premiums back if your team stays healthy.

There are far more options out there. For example, moving to level-funded High Deductible Health Plans is like setting a predictable, fixed budget for your company’s healthcare. Because you aren’t paying for the rigid, one-size-fits-all mandates of standard fully insured plans, these alternative plans can save you a massive amount of money — even if your team has a few underlying health conditions.

Working with a benefits specialist (like Jason) means you get an expert guide who can safely transition your plan, ensuring you aren’t taking on any extra risk while finally keeping those premiums in check.

High Deductible Health Plans, Healthcare building blocks, preventative care types

Myth #2: High Deductible Health Plans with HSAs shift the financial burden onto the employees. 

It’s completely natural to hear the phrase “high deductible” and immediately worry that you are abandoning your team. No good boss wants to leave their employees stranded to pay for expensive medical bills out of their own pockets before their coverage finally kicks in.

The myth is that High Deductible Health Plans are a cheap out for the employer and a raw deal for the employee. But that’s only true if the plan is offered completely on its own.

A strategic business owner doesn’t just hand over a bare-bones plan and walk away. Remember those massive savings your business gets from the much lower monthly premiums? You take a portion of those savings and use it to fund a healthcare allowance for your team.

By making regular deposits into an employee’s Health Savings Account or setting up a Health Reimbursement Arrangement, you are essentially handing them a company-funded card dedicated solely to their medical expenses.

This employer funding acts as a financial shock absorber. It bridges the gap between the doctor’s bill and the deductible, so your employees don’t have to drain their personal checking accounts to get the care they need. When designed correctly, this strategy protects your team from financial shock and turns a daunting deductible into a highly affordable healthcare experience.

Employee Benefits Package paperwork, High Deductible Health Plans with HSAs, HRAs

Myth #3: High Deductible Health Plans cause employees to skip necessary preventive care. 

As of last year, 88% of covered workers had an annual deductible they must meet before their plan covers most services. If your employees have to pay out of pocket before insurance kicks in, it’s completely logical to worry they might avoid going to the doctor just to save a few bucks. No business owner wants an HDHP to cause a sicker workforce and much worse health problems down the road.

Here is the good news: preventive care is fully included in the package, regardless of how high your deductible is.

Under current healthcare laws, in-network preventive care is treated very differently than diagnostic care. Services like annual checkups, flu shots, and standard screenings are covered at 100% right out of the gate. Your employees don’t pay a copay or coinsurance, and they do not have to touch their deductible. In fact, federal law mandates that most health plans cover dozens of specific preventive services at absolutely zero cost to the patient.

High Deductible Health Plans are actually built to encourage your team to get those free checkups and stay healthy. By removing the financial barrier for routine wellness visits, an HDHP helps your employees catch minor issues early, while encouraging them to be smarter shoppers when it comes to more expensive, elective procedures.

When paired with a funded Health Savings Account or Health Reimbursement Arrangement, you aren’t just cutting your overhead. You are building a modern, sustainable employee benefits package that genuinely protects the people who make your business run.

Ready to Build a Better Benefits Strategy? 

Changing up how you do employee benefits doesn’t have to be a headache. If you are tired of opening your annual renewal letter and cringing at the price, it’s time to look beyond the standard, off-the-rack insurance market.

You wouldn’t run your business using a rigid, one-size-fits-all strategy, so why settle for one-size-fits-all health insurance?

Transitioning to High Deductible Health Plans paired with a Health Savings Account or a Health Reimbursement Arrangement is a smart, sustainable way to take control of your overhead. By stepping away from the traditional market and exploring alternative funding, you can finally stabilize your budget while still providing a robust, protective safety net for your team.

You don’t have to navigate this transition alone.

If you’re ready to make the switch to better employee benefits, you can reach out to Jason Ferree and the rest of our team at Ashland Insurance online or give us a call!

541.482.0831 Ashland

541.857.0679 Medford